When We Fall Out: And, why do we want everything to last forever?

By Mary Dobson 

We have peculiar standards when it comes to evaluating relationships. For example: “If a friendship lasts a lifetime, it’s a good one.” “If a business partnership makes it all the way to an exit, it was predestined.” But when relationships end prematurely, we jump to the conclusion that something must have gone wrong, and look to place blame on the other party, or, possibly more often, ourselves. 

When We Fall Out: And, why do we want everything to last forever?

I see this both in my office and in my own life. When we make a new connection and form a rapport, we don’t simply enjoy the good people we find. We want to lock them in. The college roommate eventually gets promoted to a “family friend.” The beloved neighbor you walk with every morning is ultimately appointed your child’s godmother. The professional contractor who was great on one project gets hired into your organization full-time, because, if they performed this well as a contractor, just imagine what they could do with full-time hours? We give people titles: family friend, godparent, employee, work spouse, mentor. We fold them into our families, our businesses, in ways that are deeply meaningful to us. They become indispensable, indisposable. We cannot imagine our lives without them in the picture. 

And then, sometimes, despite deep compatibility, all the optimism, and the best of intentions, things fall apart. There is an impenetrable rift, you grow in different directions, an essential boundary is crossed, or you hit an impasse because they need something you’re not able to give. Now, your once-cherished friend is just the car you veer away from at school pickup, and your former trusted business partner is an employment attorney call.

What happens inside us when our relationships end? Why does it feel so much like failure? And, why is nobody talking about this, the grief of impermanence?

For some of us, “forever” is less about another person, and more likely to represent proof that we’re keepable. 

Growing up, if the people who were meant to stay, sometimes didn’t (whether physically, emotionally, or reliably), you may have learned fairly early on that closeness can vanish. Attachment researchers have been mapping this for decades: individuals with anxious attachment take breakups far harder. In a study of 5,000+, the anxiously attached reported more preoccupation, physical and emotional distress, and attempts to get relationships back, after a fissure. (Davis, Shaver & Vernon, 2003). While that research was conducted on romantic breakups, anyone who has lost a best friend knows the very same wiring gets switched on- in fact, it sometimes hurts even worse.

When a relationship that feels safe lasts, it does more than just make us happy; it soothes old fears. If it ends, that fear doesn’t just come back; it returns, this time, with evidence.

I believe we crave permanence because so little in our lives holds still. Our kids outgrow their shoes, then outgrow us. Our parents get older. Jobs change, bodies change. The town we grew up in becomes a place we visit. A friendship with a twenty year history is one of the few fixed reference points we get. They remember who we were before the marriage, before the diagnosis, before we got so good at saying we’re fine. They witness our lives unfold, with twists, turns and spoilers at every corner. Psychologists have argued that the need to belong isn’t a preference; it’s a fundamental human drive, closer to hunger than taste (Baumeister & Leary, 1995). Wanting someone to stay isn’t asking too much; it’s asking for something that we were built to need. 

So when someone we have chosen to keep decides to stop keeping us, it doesn’t land as a scheduling problem or a difference in values; it lands somewhere older, quieter and more primal, in the place where we keep the question we’ve been asking since we were small: Am I the kind of person worth holding on to? 

The first thing people tell me after a falling out is often something like: “I invested so much in this person. I feel like I wasted all of this time.” 

There is truth to this. Friendship takes longer to develop than you might think. Communication researcher Jeffrey Hall found that it takes 50+ shared hours to go from acquaintance to casual friend, 90 hours to become real friends, and more than 200 hours to become close friends (Hall, 2019). That’s weeknight dinners, school-pickup chats, birthday trips, long calls in the car; a LOT of showing up for one another. When you’re stretched thin with work and kids, you better believe that those hours come out of somewhere.

When relationships prematurely or abruptly end, our brains do math that economists and psychologists call it the ‘sunk cost effect’: the more we’ve put in, the harder it is to walk away, and the worse it feels when it’s actually time to (Arkes & Blumer, 1985). This is the same instinct that keeps us sitting through a bad movie, or powering through a terrible novel, to get a sense of finality and completion. 

Friendships and work relationships aren’t tickets, though. The hours we invested were never truly intended to be savings toward some future payout. We spent them living, laughing, helping one another, wiping tears, swapping stories, collaborating on projects, sharing meals. That time doesn’t get refunded, rewritten, or erased, if and when the relationship comes to an end.

But here is the part that really stings: After a falling out, it may feel like your entire shared history is contaminated; inside jokes, memories, secrets and all. 

There is a reason for this. Daniel Kahneman and his colleagues showed that we don’t recall experiences as an average of each moment, but rather, by the most intense moment and how they ended. This is called the ‘peak-end rule’ (Kahneman et al., 1993). A painful ending comes to narrate the entire story, even if a friendship consisted of ten good years and only two catastrophic hours.

Then, we do something even stranger: we go back and edit. She was never really my friend. He was always using me. I should have seen it from the start. We comb through old texts and emails, looking for the moment it went wrong. Once we start looking, we find it everywhere. The birthday they forgot becomes a sign. The favor they never returned becomes proof. The time they failed to join you for an important  meeting becomes deliberate sabotage. 

Of course, the Monday morning quarterback is painfully clouded by knowledge of the end, which plasters over an accurate perspective of the beginning and middle. I understand why we do it, because if it was never real, losing it shouldn’t hurt this much. Discrediting the relationship feels like protection. Unfortunately, it it costs us. Every time we decide the entire relationship was a sham, we also decide we were foolish for believing in it in the first place. We put our own judgment on trial, along with the naive version of ourselves who laughed at their jokes and confided in them. We don’t only lose the friend, we lose a little faith in the part of us that chose them, and allowed them in. 

I wish knowing this made endings hurt less.

Sometimes, when we lose a connection, we may not even be grieving the person, but rather the ease shared with them, or how easily they calmed you down when you were upset. Sometimes, we just miss having that obvious speed-dial number pinned, to call first when the day is going wrong.

Having years of backstory downloaded into each other, and a shorthand vocabulary nobody else gets, is, indeed, a treasure. It’s called ‘transactive memory’; the splitting of remembering, so each person holds pieces of shared history for one another (Wegner, Erber & Raymond, 1991). When a relationship ends, part of your memory system walks out the door. Those we’re close to become part of how we see ourselves (Aron, Aron, Tudor & Nelson, 1991), so when the relationship ends, we genuinely feel less clear about who we are (Slotter, Gardner & Finkel, 2010).

Friendship and work relationship grief have a strange and complicated shape. We grieve the future we assumed that we’d have, and the ease we earned, and assumed we’d get to keep.

When a marriage ends, people have a template for what to say. There are words; there’s a process. When a twenty-year friendship ends, there are no casseroles, no time off, no one asking how you’re holding up. Sociologist Laura Eramian, who studies how friendships end, said: “There aren’t any cultural scripts or rituals around ending a friendship” (Dalhousie University, 2019). Grief researcher Kenneth Doka calls this kind of loss ‘disenfranchised grief,’ a loss that isn’t openly acknowledged, socially mourned, or publicly supported (Doka, interviewed by KQED). Losing a friend, a business partner, or a chosen-family member fits that description perfectly.

It also hurts more than we expect. In a well-known brain imaging study, being left out of a simple online ball-tossing game lit up some of the same brain regions involved in physical pain (Eisenberger, Lieberman & Williams, 2003). If getting excluded by strangers in a game registers that way, losing someone who bore witness to your whole life is going to register.

Then, there’s the embarrassment. You introduced them as “framily.” You told everyone how lucky you were. Endings don’t just feel sad; they feel shamefully public, like you misjudged something while everyone watched on. That’s why we go quiet, desperately hoping mutuals don’t ask, “whatever happened between you and —?” Grief, we can talk about- but this feels like admitting we got it wrong.

Underneath the embarrassment, there is something even heavier. Psychologist June Tangney, who spent decades studying shame, draws a line between guilt and shame: guilt says I did something bad; shame says I am bad (Tangney & Dearing, 2002). Guilt can be repaired with an apology. Shame has nowhere to go, so it goes inward. Friendship loss is a near-perfect setup for shame, because there’s often no singular, clear wrong to point to. No affair, no betrayal. Just misunderstandings, differing interpretations of events, careless words, distance, silence, and last, an empty space where your person used to be. When there’s no clear reason, the mind supplies one. The easiest one to reach for is ourselves.

So we lie awake replaying. Was I too much? Too needy, too busy, too honest, not honest enough? We scroll back through messages at midnight, reading our words from various angles, like a prosecutor. We wonder what mutual friends think, what’s been said about us in rooms we weren’t in. For many people, one lost friendship quietly reopens all the others that came before it: the seventh-grade lunch table that stopped saving you a seat, the parent who was there and then wasn’t. The rift stops feeling like one ending and starts feeling like a pattern, with you as the common denominator.

That’s how deep it goes. The person leaves, and what stays behind is a verdict about who we are. 

Possibly the most excruciating factor here is the hesitation and fear of history repeating that ensues. After a falling out, the idea of making a new friend feels exhausting and pointless. Who has 200 more hours to download into someone? Who wants to explain their whole life again, from scratch, to another person who could also leave?

That fatigue is real, and it’s not just you. Americans are spending less time with friends than ever. A 2021 national survey found that 12% of Americans said they had no close friends at all, compared with 3% in a 1990 poll, and nearly half had lost touch with at least a few friends in the past year (Survey Center on American Life, 2021).

But here’s something that surprised me. Relationships turning over is actually completely natural, normal and expected. Dutch sociologist Gerald Mollenhorst followed 600 people for seven years and found they lost roughly half of their close network, meaning those they confided in or went to for practical help (Mollenhorst, 2009). The size of their networks stayed the same, but the characters changed. Our jobs, our kids’ schools, our neighborhoods, our hobbies, our personalities, and our needs keep moving, and the people around us move right along with them.

That begs the question: does our society place too much importance, almost to the point of pedestalization, on the goal of “lifelong friends?” I’ve heard women speak of judging other women, based on the presence or absence of childhood friends in her life, in her 40’s or 50’s. Maybe the goal should not be forever. Perhaps what’s important is that it was real while it lasted. That you showed up, it mattered, and you got what you needed during a stretch of your life.

Some relationships are seasons, and that doesn’t make them failures. Happy memories, bonded moments, and productive, generative years happened. You can grieve an ending without deciding it was all a mistake, or that you were. And, you’re allowed to start again, not because the next one is guaranteed to last, but because meaningful connections are always worth it, even when they don’t.

At LiftWell Health, we’re here to help you process difficult endings, rebuild confidence, and move forward with greater clarity. Reach out today to learn how therapy can help you heal.

Sources

Similar Posts